| Name | From | To | Notes
| | John Houghton | 1227 | | Archdeacon of Bedford. Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby. Royal writ that the Prior had secured the advowson as against Nicholas son of Bartholomew de la Leg
|
| William de Northampton | 1245 | | subdeacon. Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby
|
| Richard | 1268 | |
|
| Robert Buruil | | 1270 |
|
| William de Wyndelesore | 8 Mar 1270 | 1291 | subdeacon; Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby, on the resignation of Robert Buruil
|
| Elias de Assh/Esseby | 16 Jun 1291 | 1318 | clerk in minor orders. Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby. On presentation of D. William de Wynderhoue to St. Peter's Rectory, Northampton
|
| M. Paganus de Buckingham | 23 Jan 1318 | 1319 | Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby. On death of M. Elias de Assheby
|
| John de Clifton | 24 Mar 1319 | | acolite; Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby. On resignation of M. Paganus de Buckingham
|
| John de Ebstow | | 1324 |
|
| Nicholas de Belen | 26 Apr 1324 | | capellanus; Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby. On resignation of John de Ebstow
|
| Robert de Kildesby | 14 Nov 1332 | 1333 | clerk, Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby
|
| M. Robert de Dalderby | 19 Jan 1333 | 1334 | priest; on resignation of Robert de Kildesby. Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby
|
| Robert de Hynton | 24 Sep 1334 | | priest; on death of Robert de Dalderby. Patron, Prior & Convent of Cannons Ashby
|
| Roger Sneuell | 1 Aug 1349 | | of Ronhale, clerk
|
| John de Wodeford | 2 Nov 1349 | 1352 | on death of D. Robert
|
| M. William Castell | 9 Sep 1352 | | priest; on resignation of John de Wodeford, exchanged to Carleton Rectory
|
| D. Henry Jurdon | | 1382 |
|
| John Mertton | 20 Sep 1382 | | priest; on death of D. Henry Jurdon
|
| Robert Lacy | 10 Mar 1387 | | also vicar of Walton, Bucks.
|
| Milo Harrington | | |
|
| Thomas Poyntell | | 1468 |
|
| D. Nicholas Bateman | 6 Mar 1468 | 1471 | on death of D. Thomas Poyntell
|
| D. John Whirlett | 3 Apr 1471 | 1784 | on resignation of D. Nicholas Bateman
|
| D. John Laffenham | 18 Mar 1484 | 1501 | priest; on resignation of John Whirlot
|
| William Frankelyn | 27 Mar 1501 | 1515 | subdeacon; on death of John Laffenham
|
| M. Edward Phillip | 12 Sep 1515 | 1532 | M.A., on resignation of M. William Frankelyn
|
| D.Hugh Massy | 12 Jan 1532 | | capellanus; on resignation of D. Edward Philipe
|
| Matthew Morlande | 15 Sep 1548 | 1560 | "will dated 20 Sep 1558, to be buried in the ""quier of Thurleye Church"". Proved at Southill, 1 Nov 1558"
|
| Miles Harrington | 17 Dec 1560 | | clerk, on death of last Vicar. Patron, Queen Elizabeth
|
| William Faircliff | 9 Jan 1564 | | clerk. Patron, Queen Elizabeth
|
| William Forde | 28 Mar 1594 | |
|
| william Fourde | 20 Jun 1598 | 18 Oct 1607 | on resignation of William Fourd, last incumbent. patron, Oliver, Lord St. John of Bletsoe.
|
| William Forde | 4 Apr 1608 | 1616 |
|
| Thomas Lloyd alias Fludd | 5 May 1616 | | on resignation of William Ford
|
| Henry Spilwater | 8 Feb 1629 | 1657/8 | Patron, Oliver, Earl of Bolingbrooke. He died at Thurleigh in 1657/8, and was buried the following Jan.
|
| H.F. Brooks | May 1664 | |
|
| John Power | 1665 | | Vicar; buried 28 Oct 1705. Married at Bedford St. John on 8 May 1705 to Mary Winch of Clifton. Patron, Pawlet, St. John, Earl of Bolingbroke
|
| Edward Bourne | 10 Jun 1731 | | Buried at Bedford St. John on 5 Aug 1734. Married at Renhold 17 Oct 1731 to Sarah Willis of Bedford. Patron, Sir Jeremiah Vanaker Lambrooke, Bart.
|
| Thomas Beadles | 5 Sep 1734 | 1748 | clerk; on death of Edward Bourn. Patron, Sir Jeremiah Vanaker Lambrooke, bart. Buried 1 Dec 1748. Formerly curate of Yelden and Shelton, inducted 21 Sep 1734
|
| Robert La Rogue | 25 Jan 1748 | | clerk, on death of Thomas Beadles. Patron, ir Jeremiah Vanaker Lambrooke, bart. Inducted 28 Jan 1748. Died 1781
|
| Oliver St. John Cooper | 5 Nov 1784 | 1801 | M.A., New College, Oxon. Patron, Susanna, John Susanna, junior & Samuel Crawley & Thomas Halsey. Died 3 May 1801. Buried at Poddington
|
| Robert Moore | 10 Sep 1801 | 1833 | on death of previous incumbent. Patron, John and Samuel Crawley, esquires, Susanna, wife of John Keet, clerk & Sarah Halsey, widow. Died 18 Oct 1834, buried at Biddenham
|
| John Brereton | 25 Oct 1833 | 1938 | on resignation of Robert Moore. Patron, Samuel Crawley of Stockwood, esquire and Sarah Moore Halsey of Gaddesden, Herts.
|
| Benjamin Trapp | 26 Jan 1838 | 1900 | M.A., Clare College, Cambridge, on resignation of John Brereton. Patron, Samuel Crawley of Stockwood, esquire and Sarah Moore Halsey of Gaddesden, Herts.
|
| Robert Orr | Nov,00 | |
|
| Charles Hemsley | Apr,17 | |
|
| Alfred William Garfield Edwards | Mar,32 | |
|
| William George Branch | Feb,50 | |
|
| John Leslie Turney | | 1959 |
|
| James Alfred Prince Daniels | 1959 | 1964 |
|
| Harold Desmond Jones | 1964 | 7th Sep 1980 | Left to become Vicar at Sharnbrook
|
| David Rees | 14th July 1981 | 8th Jan 1984 | Left to become Vicar at St Martins, Bedford
|
| Andrew Peter Mottram | 1984 | 1992 |
|
| Christopher Willett Gonin | 9th Feb 1992 | 31st Aug 1997 |
|
| Victoria E.Raymer | 1998 | |
|
| Nichola & Ian McIntosh | | |
|
| Elizabeth Inall | | |
|
|